Bintel Blog

In Defense of… Francisco Franco?

By Daniel Treiman

  • Print
  • Share Share

Aharon Lapid has penned a strange article on the Spanish Civil War and fascist leader Francisco Franco for the right-wing Orthodox weekly The Jewish Press.

I’ll readily agree to the following points: The Spanish Civil War was not an entirely black-and-white affair. The Republican cause was sullied by violence and hijacked by Stalinists. The oft-romanticized Abraham Lincoln Brigade was closely tied to the utterly ignoble Soviet-controlled American Communist Party. And, yes, in the department of faint praise, it’s true that Generalissimo Franco was not as bad as Hitler — and was much nicer to the Jews.

But let’s just say that Lapid stretches a bit (to put it mildly) when he compares Franco to Abraham Lincoln:

And though he would not have liked them very much, Lincoln would have well understood — and even sympathized with — Franco’s authoritarian methods of preserving national unity. It was Lincoln, after all, who suspended habeas corpus, ignored Supreme Court decisions prohibiting civilians from being tried in military courts, and undertook several other acts of questionable legality, all for the sake of preserving the Union.

Okay, Honest Abe did curtail civil liberties during wartime. That said, it’s hard to believe that, had he not been assassinated, Lincoln would have gone on to cling to power for 29 years or carried out mass executions and imprisonment of political foes during peacetime a la Franco.



Comments
jacob Wed. Jul 9, 2008

The "utterly ignoble" CP? Don't get carried away. Scratch a white civil rights advocate from the 1930s, and most of the time you'd find a Communist--especially a southern, white civil rights activist. The civil rights movement wouldn't have happened without Communists. And the Lincoln Brigade's affiliation with the CP should, rather than tarnish the Brigade, indicate that the Party could indeed be remarkably noble.

david smith Fri. Jul 11, 2008

It's would be difficult to invent a more laughably compelling piece of evidence confirming the fact that the Jewish Press is a rancid toilet of rightwing ignorance and fanaticism.

jjl Sat. Jul 12, 2008

I do not hold a brief for fascist dictators in general, and for Franco in particular, but for the sake of historic truth, and in all fairness, it needs to be recalled that Franco not only was 'not as bad as Hitler' and 'much nicer to the Jews', but has literally saved the lives of thousands of Jews, especially in Greece, during WWII when he instructed Spanish consuls throughout Europe to provide Ladino speakers with Spanish passports (Ladino was spoken only by Jews hailing from Spain).

Would you like to receive updates about new stories?




















We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.