Bintel Blog

JVoices Announces End to Its Own Writers’ Strike

By Daniel Treiman

  • Print
  • Share Share

I recently engaged in some good-natured ribbing of the lefty blog JVoices over its announcement that it would cease publishing for the duration of the writers’ strike as an act of solidarity. I may have thought the JVoices gesture was a little bit silly, but, I must confess, I never expected that the big Hollywood studios and TV networks would manage to break the will of the obscure yet determined blog.

Now, though, JVoices mastermind Cole Krawitz has announced that his blog’s writers — like America’s late-night talk-show hosts — are headed back to work:

When we first joined the TV blogs in not posting in solidarity with the Writers Guild strike, for not just a day, but until the strike ended, we didn’t know, nor anticipate, that the strike would continue for as long as it has. As time has continued, we’ve found that silence in solidarity has been a strength–generating conversation in multiple ways–and, at a certain point, also requires reevaluation.

Before you get out your giant inflatable rats, you should know that JVoices isn’t giving up the fight. It’s just shifting strategies, exchanging its “strength–generating conversation” of “silence in solidarity” for “an innovative and fresh idea to show our support for the writers on strike.”

JVoices explained its new tactic with a press release titled, “‘JVoices’ Jewish Blog to Pay Writers 8 Cents”:

The Jewish blog, JVoices (http://prweb.com/releases/2008/1/prweb596032.htm) will begin compensating contributors 8 cents per post for every day the post remains on the front page, over a six-month period beginning January 1, 2008. The compensation amount is intended to generate increased awareness about, and support for, the current labor strike by the Writers Guild of America.

The choice of 8 cents is a reference to the struggle of the Writers Guild of America, on strike since early November. One of the demands of the Writers Guild is to double the writers’ residual payment for DVDs. An example of this, as presented in a short video (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oJ55Ir2jCxk), would be increasing the residual from 4 cents to 8 cents on a $19.99 DVD.

The question, though, is who will blog for such a pittance? The answer, I fear, is that someone will now open a sweatshop in some Third World country where workers will be forced to put in 16-hour days churning out blog posts full of grand and ineffectual gestures of solidarity for submission to JVoices. I just hope nobody gets too upset if JVoices decides to switch course and call off its payment program early.

UPDATE: Well, one man’s silly statement is another man’s meaningful gesture. A WGA member comments on JVoices that he appreciates the 8 cents gesture, writing “it means so much to us Writers Guild members that community members have been supportive of our fight for a fair contract. And it is particularly meaningful when our fellow writers support us. Your ‘8 cents’ plan is the kind of thing that helps keep us going on the picket lines.”

Also, I should clarify, I was just being cheeky when I wrote “who will blog for such a pittance?” The answer, of course — if one were to take my query at face value — would be almost everyone who blogs, as a commenter on this post helpfully notes.



Comments
talktome Thu. Jan 3, 2008

Which part of symbolic wasn't clear? And what part of the gesture didn't stand out, that if a small blog is willing to pay a residual fee of 8 cents, even for a little while, that major TV companies should have no problem? To compare them to the late night talk shows going back to work is plain misleading, let alone inaccurate. These folks aren't getting paid like that--they're probably not even getting paid at all--calling it an end to their own strike sadly misses the point, and misrepresents, what they were offering, even if you disagree with how they were offering it. But thanks for letting us know that apparently we shouldn't change what we do to reach people! God forbid! The real question, actually, is how many bloggers do you know that are getting paid?!? That might be a nice opportunity for Forward staff, but lots of--dare I say most--bloggers out there, who don't blog for papers, aren't getting paid for blogging. And I'd gander most Jewish bloggers who blog on Jewish issues. What's more of the question is why, now that the Forward has been blogging more, is it choosing to jab at smaller Jewish blogs made up of people who volunteer time and good will? Seriously?--not the best direction for The Forward.

Would you like to receive updates about new stories?






















We will not share your e-mail address or other personal information.

Already subscribed? Manage your subscription.